For those of you who live in the Midwest you are probably familiar with Door County, Wisconsin. It is a popular vacation destination for families because of its sprawling landscape, orchards, fish boils and beautiful sunsets over the lake. For me, whenever I think of Door County I think Cherries. Lots of beautiful and delicious cherries are harvested in Door County every year, 13 million pounds to be exact. Cherry season starts in mid July so we should start seeing some of those gorgeous red jewels at the farmer’s markets beginning this week.
If you like to pick your own cherries, save the date for July 18th in Door County for Summer Cherry Harvest Fest. They’ll have fun family activities such as a Cherry Pie Eating Contest and a Cherry Pit Spit Contest (although I can’t say I’d participate in that one!). I first fell in love with Door County cherries when I tasted my mother in law’s famous Cherry Pie. Every year she freezes a ton of the Door County Cherries, also known as the Montmorency Tart Cherry, to use all year round in her pies. Everyone loves her cherry pie and it is truly special. I had to adapt the recipe for my upcoming book, because I couldn’t imagine my son John never trying her amazing pies.
I made only a few changes to make the pie allergen free, but it tastes as wonderful as her version. I highly recommend using an OXO cherry pitter to make the pitting task much easier. Also, you could make this with canned tart cherries in a pinch, but I can’t emphasize enough the difference fresh-from-the-farm cherries makes in the pie. I love this pie warmed slightly with a dollop of dairy free soy ice cream. Enjoy!!
Door County Cherry Pie
My mother-in-law, Jeanne, makes this pie all year long using the fantastic tart cherries of Door County, Wisconsin. She gets them fresh during cherry season and freezes them in quart-sized freezer bags. Get in the habit of picking in-season fruit and freezing for later; your pies will thank you.
Yield: 6 servings
1 recipe Easy Pie Dough
6 cups fresh red tart cherries, pitted (or use 6 c. frozen cherries or 2 cans tart or sour pitted cherries, drained)
3 tablespoons cornstarch
3/4 cup granulated sugar
1/4 teaspoon vanilla extract
1 tablespoon dairy-free margarine, cut into pieces
Prepare Easy Pie Dough recipe as directed. Line a 9-inch pie plate with 1 rolled-out disk of dough.
In a microwave-safe bowl, combine cherries, cornstarch, and sugar, and microwave for 3 to 4 minutes, until thickened. Stir in vanilla, and pour into prepared pie pan. Dot the top with pieces of dairy-free margarine. Roll out the second disk of dough into a large 11-inch rectangle. Cut the pastry into 1/2-inch strips, and weave dough into a lattice design.
Preheat oven to 400ºF. Bake 35 to 40 minutes, until fruit is bubbling and crust is nicely browned. Cover edges with foil if the crust is browning too quickly. Cool completely on a wire rack.
Tip: If you are using canned cherries, make sure they are well drained and rinsed thoroughly. Add drops of red food coloring to give the canned cherries some of their red coloring back. Alternatively use frozen cherries.
Easy Pie Dough
Yield: Makes enough dough for a double-crust 9-inch pie
2 cups unbleached all-purpose flour
1 teaspoon granulated sugar
1/2 teaspoon salt
2/3 cup dairy-free shortening chilled and cut into small pieces
5–7 tablespoons ice water
Combine flour, sugar, and salt in food processor. Add small pieces of shortening, and pulse a few times until mixture resembles small crumbs. Add ice water, 1 tablespoon at a time, to flour mixture, pulsing until the dough just comes together. Transfer mixture to a sheet of plastic wrap. Use wrap to pull sides of dough together to form a rounded disk. Chill at least 30 minutes before using.






Mmm. Our sour cherry season just ended here. The freezer is stocked!
looks awesome, I have a great gluten free pie crust recipe too.
yum colette, i am sure it is delicious!! you are a gluten free mama!!
What dairy free soy ice cream do you use? My son is just now old enough to enjoy ice cream so we have been looking for one he can have…. or a frozen yogurt. Thanks!
Jackie, I’ve used So Delicious and Tofutti….but I am starting to venture out on making my own now. I am sure your son will love it!!
Ooooh…. I would LOVE to know how you are making your own! Perhaps that could be one of your next posts? Thanks for the info. on the store bought stuff, I’m going to look for some today
)
Also, I am going to make one of your chocolate cake or cupcake recipes for my daughter’s birthday in August because I know my son will want to have some. (Plus, my daughter is pnut/tree nut allergic.) What chocolate chips do you use? If I buy straight unsweetened cocoa powder, does cocoa have milk in it?
Thanks again…I love to cook, but I’ve never been much of a baker, so your recipes have been great for us. We just had your pancakes in our “breakfast” for dinner last night. Yum!
Thanks so much Jackie!! For the chocolate cake, I like Hersey’s Cocoa Powder, no milk in it. I also like Divvies Chocolate Chips (available by mail order only) or Enjoy Life Chocolate Chips, which is more readily available at Whole Foods. You will love this cake! My two sons are having bdays in August too!
Hi, Kelly. Just browsing your site — our 2-year-old is allergic to dairy, eggs and peanuts, and I’m just starting to try your recipes — and saw the DC cherry pie recipe. We live in Door County! The next time you’re up, please stop by our gallery and say hi. It’s called Rustic Fish Gallery (www.rusticfishgallery.com), and it’s in the Shops of Green Gables, on Hwy 42 about a mile north of downtown Ephraim. We’re open daily May-October. We’d love to meet you and promise not to talk TOO much about dealing with food allergies. (It’s difficult up here – nothing like a Whole Foods nearby; the closest shopping is in Green Bay, and that’s only ok and not great.) Anyway … enjoy the winter. – Mary Ann Rinkleff
I’m in Maryland, so I obviously didn’t use Door County cherries, but I did use some local tart cherries. This pie was SO, So good! My husband declared it his favorite. I have weird microwave issues, so I just let it set out for a while to thicken rather than microwave it, but that was my only change. Also, Kelly, I don’t see it on the site, but your cherry was also wonderful! A huge hit with recent dinner guests.
Hope all is well with your newest little guy!
The end of my comment is referring to your cherry cake. Sorry – I need to proofread!
SOOOOO excited you love this pie as much as we do! When my mother in law makes hers, I go crazy over it. There’s nothing better in the summertime!